Posted By Stephen M. Walt Share

Like some of you, I ran out of time to shop for a few people this year. But I wanted them to know what I would have gotten them if I had more time. Here are a few holiday presents that I offer in spirit (or if you prefer, in theory).

1. For Rebecca Frankel, my ace editor at FP, a new edition of Photoshop. She picks all the great pictures that accompany my posts: just imagine what she could do if she could take a stock image and alter it. How about Obama's head on Angela Merkel's body or a photo-shopped picture of Dick Cheney, Hugo Chavez, and Ayatollah Khameini swapping stories about civil liberties? Becky's done a terrific job of making this blog visually striking, and I appreciate her efforts greatly.

2. For Barack Obama, a signed copy of Taming American Power, with a bookmark at chapter 5: ("Foreign Policy in the National Interest"). Given the pounding the president took this past year from Benjamin Netanyahu and his American friends, there's nothing I could teach him about the Israel lobby, so no need to send him that one. Plus he has probably read it anyway, but just can't admit it.

3. For David Rothkopf, a DVD of Yoav Shamir's terrific documentary on anti-Semitism -- Defamation -- which he should find educational. I probably ought to include a valium with the card.

4. For my students, a promise to grade your exams in a benevolent frame of mind. That means that I promise not to start grading until at least one hour after reading the morning papers.  And if I happen to read the op-ed page of either the Washington Post or Wall Street Journal, I'll wait a good two hours.

5. For my readers: a pledge to keep trying to enlighten, amuse, and confound you in 2010. I've learned a lot from writing this blog, and I hope many of you have too. I wish you all a warm and joyous holiday, and may 2010 be more benign than a realist would expect.

DIPTENDU DUTTA/AFP/Getty Images

 
Facebook|Twitter|Reddit

PARADELIC

8:44 PM ET

December 24, 2009

Tooo funny

"And if I happen to read the op-ed page of either the Washington Post or Wall Street Journal, I'll wait a good two hours."

I got a great kick out of that comment... Your blog deals does a good job shedding light on serious issues and I visit daily, but more humor couldn't hurt.

 

JPARKS393

9:46 AM ET

December 25, 2009

why do you torture

why do you torture yourself???

"And if I happen to read the op-ed page of either the Washington Post or Wall Street Journal, I'll wait a good two hours."

and another form of torture---you should come teach at Yale instead of Harvard. :)

 

MELANCHOLY KOREAN

5:15 PM ET

December 25, 2009

i love your blog

Re Yale comment - I agree. We could use a few good realists to counterbalance all the crypto and not-so-crytop neocons.

Thanks for the wonderful blog.

 

DAVID GROSSMAN

5:41 PM ET

December 25, 2009

Photoshop? No need!

Although the financial commitment to gifts is half their importance, I'm sure your editor would be just as happy with a copy of GIMP, the Gnu Image Manipulation Program. It's got as nearly as many bells and whistles as Photoshop, and is completely free.

 

DANIEL

6:40 AM ET

December 27, 2009

How about something like the

How about something like the ButtKicker for Barack Obama's chair in the oval office?

Photoshop is great, but it used way too much by the media.

 

KHARBAUGH

1:35 AM ET

December 29, 2009

Liberal Protestants gone AWOL from Israel policy debate

Dear Professor Walt,
Here is a question I wanted to ask you and Prof. Mearsheimer when you gave an author talk on ILUSFP:
Why are liberal Protestant churches
(there might be one or two in your neck of the woods)
so notably absent from expressing outrage over
Israel's treatment of its Muslim neighbors and the U.S. complicity therewith?
Jews may control many things, but it seems a stretch to believe they control those mainstream liberal Protestant churches.
Compare, for example, their role on apartheid, Vietnam, civil rights, gay marriage, the whole left-wing PC agenda.
Remember how what seemed like the whole mainstream Christian establishment, certainly at elite institutions, was so outraged, and so public about it, over Vietnam.
Why are they silent now over Israel and, for that matter, the U.S./Muslim wars?

Best wishes to you.

 

DAVID IN DC

1:15 PM ET

December 29, 2009

Walt - don't give Rothkopf all of the valium

2009 was a year in which the public got a glimpse into the mind of Steve Walt, and the picture was telling. The shrill series of posts about the Freeman affair was typical. The posts weren't really for Freeman, but rather Walt used the affair as a springboard to launch yet more character assassination against those with whom he disagrees. There were many lowlights over the course of this year, but the over the top insinuation of dual loyalties (or perhaps, disloyalty) levelled by Walt at some of those he was attacking in these posts may have been the lowest.

Definitely save some valium for yourself, Steve. Use liberally when you get that obsessional urge to launch your frothing at the mouth ad hominems.

And in 2009 you made several calls for transparency (for others). In 2010, why don't you drop the hypocricy and provide the same?

 

Stephen M. Walt is the Robert and Renée Belfer professor of international relations at Harvard University.

Read More